BWW Reviews: SOMETHING'S AFOOT at Goodspeed is a Whydunit Mystery

The biggest mystery surrounding SOMETHING'S AFOOT isn't who's murdering guests at a posh estate on a remote island. It's why Goodspeed would decide to present a revival of such a flawed musical when there are so many other more deserving shows out there. It's not a whodunit. It's a whydunit?

The musical SOMETHING'S AFOOT originally was produced at the Goodspeed Opera House in 1973. It later opened on Broadway in 1976 and closed after 61 performances (critics haven't been fans), but in what is really a mystery, it went on to have a run in London where it was nominated for an Olivier Award in 1977. It's puzzling, since this supposed spoof of Agatha Christie mysteries isn't very funny and the music and lyrics don't fit the mood (score, lyrics and the book are credited to James McDonald, David Vos and Robert Gerlach, with additional music by Ed Linderman). 

This production, conceived by Casey Hushion, but directed by Choreographer Vince Pesce when she had to pull out because of an illness in her family, doesn't solve the mystery of how to make the show work either. Pregnant pauses wait for punch lines that are dead on arrival; musical numbers go on forever and a character's cry of "one more time" isn't exactly welcome.

In the middle of the action (and I use the term liberally) actors are singing songs titled "I Don't Know Why I Trust You (But I Do)," "Dinghy," and "The Legal Heir" with lyrics like "Pooh, pooh, stiff upper lip," and "remember Queen Victoria" while unbelievably doing things like whirling about, leaping up on furniture or twirling spears…. 

Add to these problems the following: ensemble singing that's off-key; a character actress who shouldn't be cast in a singing role; an ensemble that doesn't seem to have come together as one (an understudy went on for one of the leads on opening night); and a still-in-rehearsals feel to a production that's been running in previews for nearly a month. Now you have a clue as to what the real crime is. 

But enough said about what doesn't work. A perfect storm like this is pretty unusual at the Opera House. Let's just leave it at that and take a quick look at the story and some of the things that do deserve a pat on the back. 

It's 1935 (the actors are dressed in stereotypical period costumes by Designer Tracy Christensen) and one by one, guests arriving at the isolated Rancour Retreat (set designer Adrian W. Jones creates a stately mansion) end up dead. The first to go is Clive (Ron Wisniski), so we assume the butler didn't do it. But who did? 

Could it be the maid, Lettie (Liz Pearce), the caretaker Flint (Khris Lewin) or family physician Dr. Grayburn (Peter Van Wagner)? Perhaps it's Nigel Rancour (Benjamin Eakeley who lends a nice voice), the nephew of the retreat's owner who sent invitations to all of the guests for an unknown reason. Or could it be the lovely, young Hope Langdon (Julia Osborn -- I saw understudy Alyssa Gagarin) who becomes romantically involved with Geoffrey (Hunter Ryan Herdlicka) who unexpectedly turns up at the retreat amidst the thunder, rain and murder? Cue the spooky organ music… (Michael O'Flaherty music directs and conducts the seven-member orchestra.) 

Also under suspicion are Lady Grace Marley-Prowe (Lynne Wintersteller, who has a very nice singing voice) and Army Col. Gillweather (Ed Dixon whose humor helps break things up a little). Will amateur detective Miss Tweed (Audrie Neenan) crack the case before the last victim is dragged off to the library?